Buying the Carsons’ House

So, my house…it seduced me. My husband and I were uncertain about moving here, so we’d take long drives up from Chicago and cruise the streets and poke around.


JCrewville is so pretty.  It looks like a small New England town with big trees and old houses –not a McMansion in sight. Leafy, with sidewalks (on which to walk your Golden Retriever), it has a downtown lit by old-fashioned gaslights, and a lake that hosts sailing lessons and an annual triathlon.


It’s gorgeous, but it was the house that sold me –a tall Tudor with a heaping mound of hydrangeas in front. It was one of only two for sale at the time. When we saw it I yelled out “Oooooo!! Can you imagine?” We stalked it for weeks, visited it three times and two months later, it was ours.


At least, it was ours on paper.  I learned soon after moving that houses here are often referred to by their most long-standing owners: the “Sheridans’ house” or the “Austins’ place”.  It turns out, we had bought the Carsons’ house…and the Carsons were moving only five blocks away.


Whenever I asked anyone for directions and told them my address, they’d say “Oh, you live in the Carsons’ house.” I heard this so often that after a couple of weeks, if someone asked me where I lived, I’d say (somewhat dejectedly) “In the Carsons’ house.”


And it felt like the Carsons’ house.  They had left a few stamps of their ownership behind – a growth chart on a doorway molding marked eight years of life for their three children.  Their shower curtains still hung territorily in the bathrooms.  Mr. Carson told my neighbor to ask me to look for his wedding ring.  He was sure he had lost it in the bathroom behind the radiator (which seemed a little Freudian to me).


The day we moved in, I found a big glob of peanut butter in the kitchen sink.  I was pissed and a little self-conscious about wiping it up. More proof that their bustling life had just exited the building. We received bundles of their mail that I collected in grocery bags and left on their new stoop. I found a silver bracelet on a doorknob that I threw in there as well.They’d been here a while, I reasoned. There were bound to be leftovers.   


Turns out, they weren’t sure they had really wanted to move.  I heard from my neighbor that Mrs. Carson had cried for weeks before the move. Mr. Carson had told the neighbors the eight years in the house were the longest he’d lived in any one place.


Though we had paid for it and moved our stuff in, I couldn’t help feeling like we had evicted them.  We were the intruders that had forced them out.  I wondered if the house sensed they were gone.  Did it miss them?


Everyone knew the Carsons. They were the same age as us, but in our new small pond, they were big fish. It was clear from their continuous incoming mail: they sat on charity boards, he was involved in city politics and Mrs. Carson was, of course, president of the PTA.


After our first block party, my neighbor kept talking about how much she missed them.  The “party just wasn’t the same” without them.  They were “the glue that held everyone on the street together”. 


It fueled an increasingly odd dynamic with the Carsons.  Though polite, from a distance, we could feel them eyeing us. We too, were guarded and suspicious despite our outward pleasantries.  We were the new second wife living in the first wife’s house.


Even after they moved to a bigger house on a leafier street, they were still attached to our house.  I learned after our first vacation that they peeked through our windows to see what we had done to the place.  I heard that Mr. Carson was telling people he wished he had never sold it. My neighbor told me repeatedly that the Carsons were waiting for us to invite them over for coffee.


We never did. I was getting sick of hearing about the bloody Carsons. We were the new people in town…no welcome wagon was calling me for coffee.


I was having a horrible time coping with my transition from working city mom to stay-at-home suburban mom. I was in the throes of a shattering identity crisis.  The idea that I had stolen the home of the friggin’ mayor and first lady was too much for me.


I tried to steer clear of them.  I didn’t want to invade Mrs. Carson’s territory any more than I apparently had.  I kept a distance from lovely people because they were her friends.  I didn’t join any clubs or volunteer in places where I knew she was involved.  But because she was everywhere, I ended up carving a very narrow space for my own path. In hindsight, it was stupid to feel so apologetic, but I was so blinded by transitional shock, I didn’t have any chutzpah left in me. 


It’s been seven long years now.  We’ve remodeled every room, painted over the Carsons’ growth chart and started our own. Aside from some pretty curtains in the master bedroom and our living room drapes (“very expensive drapes” according to Mr. Carson), we’ve made this house our own.  My kids know no other home but this one.


We’re still distantly friendly with the Carsons.  We have mutual friends, but we’re not in their same circle. We are ex-spouses that remain amicable because we both love the house.    


Recently I got to know a new friend, a mother of one of Elizabeth’s classmates.  She was dropping off her daughter and needed directions.  When I told her my address she said, “Oh you live in the Carsons’ house.”


“No,” I replied, “ I used to.”

5 thoughts on “Buying the Carsons’ House

  1. I love this post, and not just because you linked to me. I love it because we went through a similar feeling when we bought our house. It’s not as nice as yours – it was most definitely a “starter” home that somehow we’ve found ourselves in for almost ten years now… but the people who lived here before loved it MORE than we did and even left it a “goodbye” letter on the mantle when they left. We read it, thought, okay, sweet, whatever, and promptly tossed it. I mean, it was OUR house now, right? What am I gonna do with a letter like that? Frame it? Umm, no.

    They came back a few years ago, drove by to see the old haunt, you know, that kind of thing. And they ASKED US WHERE THE LETTER WAS.

    I just stared at both of them until they felt uncomfortable and left.

    Omigosh that is about the craziest thing I have ever heard. I guess they did love the house MORE than you. Perhaps you should just move out and leave it as an empty shrine, a testament to the owners who loved it the best…or maybe you had better get busy writing a BETTER love letter so your house knows which family has the REAL literary talent.

  2. Your post makes me wonder if any of our old homes are known in the same way. Oh, that’s the ___________’s house! Does it make you think the same thing? It sounds like you have definitely made it your home now though — maybe in another year or so the rest of the town will accept it as yours and yours alone.

    And, JCrewville sounds really lovely — like my perfect little town!

    There’s no denying it, JCrewville is pretty…it just comes with its own vibe that takes some getting used to.

    There’s only one way to know if your town also classifies its home by its owners…ask for directions 🙂

  3. Good grief. What a mess small towns are. How strange that they were so attached to the house but sold it anyway. I have fond memories of the house I grew up in, and I fantasize about peeking in the windows, but it was my parents house and not mine. So weird. But it sounds like you made it YOURS finally, and that is a good thing.

    Yeah, I guess I can’t really blame them for peeking — we drive by and try to peek in on our old condo in Chicago every time we (sigh) go back to the city.

    I guess home OWNERSHIP is really a state of mind…that is, after we’ve mortgaged ourselves to the gills. And anytime the Carsons want to make us an offer…

  4. Love your blog…having moved from New Jersey to a small midwestern town, I can totally relate to you. Our house also came with its own reputation. Sometimes I really miss the anonymity of being in a more populated area!

    It’s so funny that you would say that…I’ve often said anonymity is the single biggest thing I miss the most living here. I’m so glad to hear someone else gets that. Thanks for stopping by.

  5. This has ‘suspense movie’ written all over it. Another lovely read. Please do not ever leave JCrewville (though I know you’re writing would entertain no matter the locale).

    Yay! It’s good to hear from you again.
    It doesn’t look like we’ll be moving anytime soon — due to my husband’s job and my strong desire to have my kids have what I didn’t: a childhood home (I moved every three years growing up)…plus, I need the material 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s